OPINION: Why Outstanding Senior is Overrated

OPINION: Why Outstanding Senior is Overrated

1246 views

As the homecoming game approaches on October 7th, alumni flock to their alma mater, first years prepare for the inevitable 15 pound weight gain from McDougal’s chicken, and parents enthusiastically buy a third set of gold pom poms. Seniors, however, fake smiles and cheers as their peers are acknowledged for accomplishing the “Most Outstanding Senior” title. However, what many do not realize is that the process of picking Vanderbilt’s most outstanding senior is inherently flawed.

Beginning with a nomination from a student organization, or occasionally a faculty member, the selection starts with what is essentially a popularity contest. Within organizations, many administer a democratic vote to most fairly choose their nominee. More often than not, the executive board, composed of seniors, delivers a poll for members to choose among those considered; ironically, the person nominated is often the one leading the vote in the first place. If, however, the organization is more discreet in their biases, an underclassmen will conduct the vote. The result is the same- the more name recognition garnered by a member the more votes he or she receives.

The requirement of nomination by an organization is rooted in privilege. Most clubs meet after the end of the school day or on weekends. These times, however, are the same times available for students to work for an income. Students who must work to sustain themselves will likely be involved in fewer clubs than those with free nights and weekends. Thus, the sheer number of clubs students of lower socioeconomic status are able to join puts them at a decreased likelihood of nomination. Because students who work cannot participate in as many clubs, it is likely that those who are nominated do not reflect this population. This truth perpetuates the stereotype that Vanderbilt’s student population is, inherently, wealthy. Of course, many students who do not meet this stereotype are pushing boundaries and becoming campus leaders, but the likelihood is not as high. Labelling a student involved in multiple clubs as the “most” outstanding infers superiority over those who worked four jobs while maintaining a 4.0 GPA. While both are certainly outstanding, only one meets Vanderbilt’s definition.

After an interview round with three staff and faculty members to narrow down nominees, the last step in the outstanding senior selection process includes publishing perfectly lit headshots and allowing students to vote on who they believe is the most qualified. Unlike previous years, the 2017 Outstanding Senior contest did not have biographies visibly attached to each candidate’s name, so voting was based almost entirely off of name recognition unless you noticed a small “i” icon next to the names and clicked each. While many students would like the outstanding senior to represent the student body, it is difficult to decipher who is positioned to do that without some sort of obvious description of involvement. With the student body left to select their most outstanding senior representative via vote, the entire process is turned, once again, into nothing more than a popularity contest. While this alone has its own merit, perhaps “Vanderbilt’s Most Popular Senior” is more appropriate considering the selection routine.

Thankfully, the Vanderbilt’s Most Outstanding Senior contest is becoming increasingly diverse with each year, and the nominees continue to inspire. Each nominee is truly outstanding and has a monumental impact on Vanderbilt’s campus. After three full years at an elite university, every fourth year Vanderbilt student is qualified to walk the field at homecoming under the “Outstanding Senior” title. No matter the club involvement or leadership positions, every single student contributed uniquely to the special environment and culture of Vanderbilt. Nominated or not, each senior at Vanderbilt is outstanding.

About author

Alexandra Doten

Allie is a Vanderbilt University junior majoring in Human and Organizational Development. Allie has a passion for domestic political issues, particularly those pertaining to racial and gender inequalities, as well as other human rights problems. She works for NASA during her breaks from school, where she participates in Students Against Modern Slavery, Vanderbilt Protecting Animal Welfare Society, Kappa Delta sorority, Vanderbilt Democrats, and Vanderbilt feminists in addition to her role with the Vanderbilt Political Review. In her free time, Allie watches too many 80’s movies and frequents Chipotle.

Comments
  • Tractor Workshop Manuals#1

    April 18, 2019

    IпїЅпїЅve really enjoyed reading your content. You obviously know what you might be having a debate about! Your websites are simple to navigate too, IпїЅпїЅve bookmarked it inside favourites. . . . .

    Reply
  • John Deere Technical Manuals#2

    April 16, 2019

    Some genuinely fantastic information, Glad I observed this.

    Reply
  • Allen#3

    April 13, 2019

    exactly how come some blogs in a blogroll do not have their most recent post listed and also others do? Exactly how to alter that?

    Reply
  • John Deere Technical Manuals#4

    April 10, 2019

    Good write-up, IЎ¦m regular visitor of oneЎ¦s site, maintain up the nice operate, and It is going to be a regular visitor for a lengthy time. Pristina Travel

    Reply
  • Danial#5

    April 10, 2019

    How do I export from blogger to wordpress without ruining indexed permalinks?

    Reply
  • additional resources#6

    April 7, 2019

    I’m trying to find blogs that have really great advice on what’s in fashion and what the best makeup is..

    Reply
  • John Deere Service Manuals#7

    April 7, 2019

    Nice post. I discover some thing tougher on distinct blogs everyday. It will always be stimulating to read content from other writers and employ something there. I’d would prefer to apply certain with the content on my own weblog whether you don’t mind. Natually I’ll provide a link on your internet weblog. Appreciate your sharing.

    Reply
  • John Deere Repair Manuals#8

    April 6, 2019

    Wow! This can be one particular of the most useful blogs We have ever arrive across on this subject. Actually Magnificent. I’m also a specialist in this topic therefore I can understand your hard work.

    Reply
  • clarks shoes#9

    April 5, 2019

    Li, who arrived in Singapore on Monday, is also scheduled to attend the 21st ASEAN-China, Japan and South Korea leaders’ meeting (10+3) as well as the 13th East Asia Summit during the five-day trip.

    Reply
  • more info here#10

    April 2, 2019

    I simply want to say I am beginner to weblog and actually liked this page. Most likely I’m likely to bookmark your site . You actually have tremendous writings. Regards for sharing with us your webpage.

    Reply
  • nike shoes#11

    April 2, 2019

    ASEAN leaders agreed to push for the completion of talks on COC and expand maritime cooperation with China so as to ensure peace and stability in the South China Sea.

    Reply
  • fitflop#12

    April 2, 2019

    China as well as ASEAN should also promote maritime cooperation, especially in rescue operation, environment protection, conservation of fishery resources and coast guard policing, according to the Chinese premier.

    Reply
  • kate spade handbags#13

    April 2, 2019

    Former Italian Prime Minister Romano Prodi also said in a interview with China News ministry that Italy could be a protagonist in Belt as well as Road cooperation with China.

    Reply
  • swarovski jewelry#14

    April 2, 2019

    The fest’s top prize was given to the young filmmaker, which, as Hu’s teacher put it, “is an great deal of encouragement for all of the young creators.” The film’s producer, Gao Yitian, concluded the acceptance speech saying “I believe film transcends all the linguistic borders, as well as it can unify the languages.”

    Reply
  • adidas yeezy shoes#15

    March 31, 2019

    “FINISHING KICK” OF RCEP TALKS

    Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *