Stories and Storytellers: Reflections on the State of the Union

Stories and Storytellers: Reflections on the State of the Union

72 views

Dozens of journalists and pundits have compared President Trump to the hero of All the King’s Men (a novel written by Vanderbilt alum Robert Penn Warren), the fictional governor Willie Stark, who was based on populist politician Huey Long, because Stark and Long were also political outsiders, known for free-range public speaking, accused of having authoritarian tendencies. At the end of the novel, Sugar Boy Sheehan, lamenting Willie Stark’s death, stutters, “He could t-t-talk so good.” The narrator, who worked with Sugar Boy in the governor’s office, wonders: Was the Boss the Boss because he could talk good, or did Sugar Boy listen to him and like his speeches because he was the Boss?

President Trump’s State of the Union address might provide insight to the question plaguing Warren’s narrator, for the speech was dominated not as much by discussion of his achievements or policy proposals for the next year as it was by stories. He brought in twenty guests, whose stories together accounted for over a quarter of the eighty-minute speech (the third longest in history). On tax reform, immigration, relations with North Korea, Middle Eastern policy, and nearly every other issue on the table, he had someone in the audience with whom we could sympathize as the camera zoomed in and they cried, saluted, or smiled. Vanderbilt history professor and expert on U.S. foreign relations Dr. Thomas Schwartz commented, “Trump’s State of the Union followed in a tradition begun by Ronald Reagan in bringing ‘featured guests’ along to make certain political points. To some extent this probably helped the speech, as it allowed Trump to shift attention away from himself and toward some of the causes and issues he supports.”

Writers at the Wall Street Journal and The Atlantic have also described these vignettes as distractions. With the recent government shutdown (and another looming just around the corner) and the ongoing investigations into his associates’ involvement with Russia, distraction may well be what President Trump needs. After all, only 40.4% of voters approve of his first year in office, and 54.6% say the country is “on the wrong track.” For many, the vignettes allowed him to make the same political points that have upset so many of his opponents, while at the same time sounding optimistic and compromising.

But maybe these vignettes, stories, and pieces of the larger narratives are more than just tactics. Maybe last Tuesday’s speech showed the wisdom of what Plato wrote in The Republic two thousand years ago: “The ones who tell the stories rule society.” Maybe last Tuesday’s State of the Union address is evidence for the power that stories have over us, and the power that storytellers have over us.

Bringing in the twenty outside guests allowed President Trump to add new stories to broader narratives that have propelled him into the Oval Office. That Mexicans are sneaking into the country, taking government benefits, and stealing “our” jobs. That the U.S. is losing on trade deals and defense. That the economy is sinking and that the working class can make a comeback. That politicians are rotten and the country needed an outsider to “drain the swamp.” That voters must elect him to retake the country and make America great again. In the Republican primary, he told these stories with more clarity, color, and storytelling skill than any of his opponents. His campaign and his first year in office have been defined by the larger narratives which he has told—and the language has caught on. Make America great again. Fake news. His opponents might counter that his rhetoric has little relation to reality. And yet the language he has popularized has created a reality of its own.

Not all of the stories told in his speech fit squarely with narratives that are uniquely Trump’s own. Professor Schwartz added, “It was striking how much a defense of human rights in North Korea, and a general defense of human freedom the President made, considering how critical he has been in the past about American interventions to spread democracy. This may well signify the degree to which almost any American President, whatever their views on foreign relations, feels compelled to embrace American exceptionalism and an ideological approach to some foreign policy questions.” These meta-stories of American exceptionalism and the need to spread American ideals have given the United States extraordinary power on the world stage.

There is another side to the narrator’s question: As much as power comes out of stories, stories—the ones that are heard, the ones that penetrate our thinking—come out of power. Perhaps these stories have caught on not because of their own merit, but because Trump has been able to tell them from a position of power. After all, the reason that 46 million watched Trump’s speech is because he’s the President. He has the audience he does because he is speaking from such a position of power. With his base, even the false stories he tells catch on, because they believe what he says.

On the other hand, Democrats have responded to the President’s rise with a narrative that refers to the very nature of the connection between stories and power. Members of marginalized groups—women, African-Americans, LGBT individuals, immigrants—have not had their stories told, and Trump’s narratives either take power from these groups or silence their voices. These were the main themes of Rep. Joe Kennedy III’s response to the State of the Union, and they have been the main narrative of Trump’s opposition. In recent years, language used to describe mistreatment of individuals in these groups (mansplaining, micro-aggressions, tokenization, etc.) has empowered the marginalized.

On Tuesday, President Trump tried to steal his opponents’ language and turn this narrative on its head. Trump spoke of the “American dream” and spun the word Democrats have used to describe children brought into the U.S. illegally, “dreamers,” on its head. When he said, “Americans are dreamers too,” both sides of the immigration debate heard him loud and clear. He brought in the parents of two Hispanic teens killed by MS-13 gang members, and brought in a Hispanic Immigrations and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agent, Celestino Martinez, who tracked down MS-13 gang members in Long Island. Kashana Cauley of the New York Times has called out these examples for what they are: “egregious cases of tokenism.” Before boarding her plane to Washington D.C., Evelyn Rodriguez, one of the two mothers at the State of the Union whose daughter was killed, said, “I’m not here for anyone’s political gain.” But the President’s confident facial expression, as the cameras zoomed in on the two mourning couples, made it clear: he was manipulating their story to lend power to his cause.

So, does power come from the telling of stories and the use of language? Or do stories and the truths they express come from power itself? The President’s speech tonight reminds us of one thing we can know for sure: the relationship between stories and power is an important one indeed. The Trump Administration and the Republican majorities have made a great many promises for the 2018 year. Whether or not they will deliver on these promises depends not as much on the smaller political battles or dollars and cents as they will on the opposing factions’ abilities to use stories and language to achieve their goals.

About author
Comments
  • tory burch#1

    January 11, 2019

    My spouse and i have been absolutely thankful that Edward managed to complete his studies using the ideas he had from your own site. It is now and again perplexing just to choose to be freely giving information and facts a number of people may have been trying to sell. So we fully grasp we need the writer to give thanks to for this. All the explanations you have made, the simple blog menu, the friendships your site make it easier to foster – it’s got mostly incredible, and it’s really helping our son and our family imagine that the topic is entertaining, and that’s seriously serious. Thanks for all the pieces!

    Reply
  • offwhite#2

    January 10, 2019

    I and my buddies ended up reviewing the excellent key points on your web site then unexpectedly got a terrible suspicion I had not expressed respect to you for those tips. All the men ended up totally passionate to learn them and have extremely been taking pleasure in these things. Appreciation for really being simply considerate as well as for making a decision on varieties of great subject areas millions of individuals are really wanting to be aware of. My sincere apologies for not expressing gratitude to you sooner.

    Reply
  • yeezys#3

    January 9, 2019

    Thank you so much for providing individuals with an exceptionally superb chance to read articles and blog posts from this site. It can be so pleasurable plus full of fun for me and my office acquaintances to visit your website on the least three times in a week to learn the fresh tips you have. And of course, we’re actually contented with your effective tricks you serve. Some 2 points in this article are honestly the most suitable we have ever had.

    Reply
  • timberland outlet#4

    January 8, 2019

    My husband and i have been quite relieved that Emmanuel managed to deal with his basic research out of the precious recommendations he gained through the web page. It is now and again perplexing to simply continually be handing out tips and tricks which often the others may have been making money from. So we already know we have the blog owner to appreciate for that. All of the illustrations you’ve made, the straightforward site menu, the friendships your site help instill – it is many spectacular, and it’s making our son in addition to the family reckon that that subject matter is enjoyable, which is particularly vital. Many thanks for everything!

    Reply
  • nike epic react#5

    January 8, 2019

    I’m also writing to make you be aware of of the extraordinary discovery my daughter obtained reading your webblog. She learned such a lot of details, most notably how it is like to have a very effective giving heart to get a number of people with ease learn specific extremely tough subject matter. You truly did more than visitors’ desires. Thanks for distributing such warm and helpful, safe, explanatory and unique tips on that topic to Mary.

    Reply
  • chrome hearts online#6

    January 7, 2019

    I needed to draft you the little bit of remark in order to give many thanks over again about the remarkable suggestions you have shared above. This has been certainly seriously open-handed with people like you to present freely all a few people could possibly have supplied for an electronic book to get some bucks on their own, chiefly now that you might have tried it if you desired. Those concepts as well served to become great way to comprehend some people have a similar desire just as mine to grasp somewhat more regarding this issue. I think there are numerous more fun moments up front for those who scan through your blog.

    Reply
  • golden goose sneakers#7

    January 7, 2019

    I must point out my affection for your kindness giving support to people who must have help on your situation. Your real commitment to passing the solution up and down has been remarkably informative and has continuously encouraged some individuals much like me to arrive at their objectives. Your own invaluable key points denotes so much a person like me and still more to my colleagues. Thanks a ton; from each one of us.

    Reply
  • longchamp handbags#8

    January 6, 2019

    I together with my pals were examining the great things on your site and suddenly developed an awful suspicion I had not thanked the blog owner for those techniques. These guys are actually joyful to study them and have really been loving these things. Thanks for really being indeed considerate and also for making a decision on some helpful areas millions of individuals are really desirous to know about. Our own sincere regret for not expressing appreciation to you sooner.

    Reply
  • adidas yeezy boost#9

    January 5, 2019

    My wife and i got now satisfied Raymond could finish up his inquiry via the ideas he received using your weblog. It is now and again perplexing to just choose to be giving away guides that many a number of people may have been selling. And now we recognize we now have the writer to appreciate because of that. All the explanations you’ve made, the simple web site navigation, the relationships you will help foster – it’s got all impressive, and it’s helping our son in addition to us consider that the subject is interesting, which is wonderfully important. Many thanks for all the pieces!

    Reply
  • golden goose#10

    January 5, 2019

    I must convey my passion for your kindness in support of persons who require assistance with that area of interest. Your special dedication to passing the solution all through had become extremely functional and has continuously made folks just like me to arrive at their endeavors. Your personal important tutorial indicates much a person like me and much more to my peers. Thank you; from everyone of us.

    Reply
  • golden goose#11

    January 4, 2019

    I am commenting to let you understand what a brilliant encounter our girl gained reading through your web site. She came to understand such a lot of issues, most notably what it’s like to have an incredible helping mood to make certain people with ease master chosen extremely tough matters. You really exceeded people’s expectations. Thank you for producing those informative, dependable, educational and cool thoughts on your topic to Emily.

    Reply
  • balenciaga speed#12

    January 3, 2019

    I precisely desired to thank you very much yet again. I’m not certain the things I would have done in the absence of the actual points revealed by you relating to such situation. It actually was a real hard condition for me, but looking at a professional fashion you treated the issue made me to leap with fulfillment. Extremely grateful for your support and as well , wish you recognize what an amazing job you were providing training the rest with the aid of your website. Most likely you have never got to know any of us.

    Reply
  • off white shoes#13

    January 3, 2019

    Thank you for all of your labor on this blog. My mum take interest in conducting investigations and it is simple to grasp why. A number of us hear all of the lively ways you produce vital guides by means of your blog and recommend participation from other ones on this area so our own simple princess is now discovering a great deal. Have fun with the rest of the new year. You are performing a dazzling job.

    Reply
  • crazy explosive#14

    January 1, 2019

    I truly wanted to develop a simple word in order to express gratitude to you for these pleasant recommendations you are showing on this website. My time consuming internet research has at the end of the day been honored with wonderful information to exchange with my classmates and friends. I would repeat that most of us readers are extremely lucky to be in a perfect network with so many marvellous professionals with beneficial methods. I feel rather privileged to have seen your entire website and look forward to tons of more fun minutes reading here. Thanks a lot once again for everything.

    Reply
  • caterpillar shoes#15

    January 1, 2019

    My wife and i ended up being so ecstatic that Emmanuel managed to finish off his studies via the precious recommendations he acquired out of your blog. It is now and again perplexing just to always be releasing guidance which some other people have been making money from. And we also fully understand we need you to give thanks to for this. The specific explanations you’ve made, the simple website menu, the friendships your site aid to promote – it is everything impressive, and it’s really making our son in addition to us do think that article is brilliant, and that is highly vital. Thank you for all!

    Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *