How Vanderbilt’s Third Party Voters Feel

How Vanderbilt’s Third Party Voters Feel


This article was written by Abigail Fournier and includes testemonies gathered by Fournier and Connor Saeman.


“For those that didn’t vote or voted third party because ‘of course she’s going to win’: she didn’t. So now you get to live with the consequences of your protest vote or your apathy.” These were the thoughts of Yamilla Saiegh, Vanderbilt sophomore from Miami Dade County, Florida. She shares a sentiment  with many angry Democratic voters who notice that third party candidates collectively gained a quantity of votes that could have overcome Trump’s margins in important swing states like Florida and Michigan.

Third party candidates in 2016, including Gary Johnson of the Libertarian party and Jill Stein of the Green party, collectively took about 5.2 million votes on election day, which constituted 4% of the popular vote, according to Time election coverage. Back in late August/early September, these candidates were polling at even higher numbers when Gary Johnson peaked, polling at 9%. Evan McMullin, a former Republican from Utah who ran as an independent in the election, entered the race in August. He was transparent concerning his goals, which were to simply win one or two states and keep Trump and Clinton from gaining enough electoral votes to win the presidency. In this case, the House of Representatives would have been left to decide the president. McMullin ended up coming in third in his home state of Utah with 20% of the vote, where his chances were the best.

ABC Polls found that after the peak in third party support in August, backing for Johnson, Clinton, and McMullin generally decreased as election day approached. On November 7, these polls predicted that Johnson would get 4% of the popular vote and that Stein would get 1% of the popular vote; these predictions ended up overstating Johnson’s popularity, as he ultimately received 3% of the popular vote.

If Johnson and Stein had been less popular on voting day, we might have seen very different electoral college results. According to election data from, these third party candidates collectively gained enough votes that they could have overturned final results in 13 states had their voters instead chosen to vote for one of the two major-party candidates. Seven of these 13 states were won by Clinton, including Virginia, New Mexico, New Hampshire, Nevada, and Maine. Six of these states went for Trump, including Florida, Michigan, Pennsylvania, and Utah. Perhaps the most pronounced difference that third party votes made was in Michigan, where Johnson and Stein collectively took 222,4000 votes (5% of the popular vote), according to NBC polling data. Trump only had a 15,600 vote lead over Clinton in Michigan, so these third party votes were especially important.

2016 was a very strong year for third party candidates. They took votes away from both Hillary Clinton and Donald Trump in important swing states, and in many cases, they could have been the difference between Trump and Clinton victories. It is important to think about who Johnson and Stein took votes away from; according to data from from before election day, Johnson’s support was 10% Democratic, 25% Republican, and 65% independent. In states like Florida where Gary Johnson received more votes than the margin between Clinton and Trump, it is reasonable to estimate that Trump’s margin could have been even higher if Johnson voters chose to vote for either Clinton or Trump, as most of them would have voted for Trump. However, if Stein’s supporters had voted for Hillary in Florida, these margins would have been different. This Florida data is reminiscent of the 2000 election, when Ralph Nader of the Green Party received 97,421 votes in Florida, when Bush beat Gore by only 537 votes in the sunshine state. Many speculate that Nader’s supporters secured Bush’s win in 2000, as it is reasonable to presume that Nader took more votes from Gore than he did from Bush.

Ultimately, it is impossible to guess how third party voters would have voted if they had chosen to vote for one of the major party candidates; however, it is important to understand their huge impact in this election. For many frustrated and surprised Democrats like Yamilla Saiegh, third party voters ruined Clinton’s chances this year.

This election brings into question whether we should vote strategically or based on who our political views align with the most. For voters who did not want Trump to win in Florida, voting for Jill Stein or Gary Johnson effectively meant giving Trump an advantage, as Hillary Clinton was his only opponent that had a chance of beating him. This is true for Republicans in states like New Hampshire who chose to vote for one of the third party candidates; in a way, this can be seen as a vote for Hillary, who ended up beating Trump with close margins.

As citizens of a democratic republic where we all have the right to make our own voting decisions, I argue that no one has the authority to tell someone else how to vote, especially whether to prioritize voting strategically or voting for the person that most aligns with our political views. However, I believe it is important for Americans to think about how their votes for third party candidates help and hurt major party candidates in their state. In this election, polling data prior to the election was misleading in many states like Florida where a Clinton win was forecasted. It is possible that voters here made the decision to vote for third party candidates on the premise that Clinton was likely to win the sunshine state regardless of their vote. Only time and research will tell whether voters considered the impact of their third party vote based on these false premises.

Here we include the testimonies of several Vanderbilt students who decided to vote for third party candidates.

“As an Independent voter from a solid blue state, I chose to vote for Gary Johnson, because his views most closely aligned with my own. Realizing that Johnson did not have a chance of winning the general election, I was hoping for a Clinton win on election day and was confident that my state would give its electoral votes to her. Therefore, I did not view my vote for Johnson as a vote for Trump; I viewed it as a protest vote, signifying my dissatisfaction with both candidates. If I lived in a swing state, I certainly would have thought differently about my vote for a third party candidate. However, because Clinton was going to win my state no matter who I voted for, I decided to cast a vote for the candidate whose views most aligned with mine”

-Anonymous, Vanderbilt sophomore

“I am a Republican voter from a solid blue state (California), and I chose to vote for Gary Johnson. I will not apologize for voting the way I did, as I absolutely could not align myself with either Trump or Clinton. As a registered GOP voter I had to compromise in a significant way just to vote for a third-party candidate. I sacrificed my party loyalty to challenge two candidates that I did not think were fit to be president. I, a moderate conservative, should not have had to sacrifice most, if not all, of my core political principles in order to save this country from a misogynist reality TV star. Like many on this campus, I fear the direction this country is now headed. I only hope that we can all stop pointing fingers and start gearing up for an era of political uncertainty fueled by political unrest and unresolved divisiveness. We will need our country’s best minds observing, analyzing, and countervailing any failed efforts on the part of Trump to make America great again.”

-Anonymous, Vanderbilt sophomore

“So I think the two party system is just so broken. Both parties believe in such contradictory ideals. I definitely don’t agree with everything Gary Johnson does, but I felt like I didn’t want to vote for Hillary because it would only be to vote against Trump. I guess I just voted my conscience and even though I knew he wasn’t going to win the promotion of a multiple party system is important to me.”

-Anonymous, Vanderbilt junior

About author

Abigail Fournier

Abigail is a sophomore at Vanderbilt from Far Hills, New Jersey. She is studying Human and Organizational Development, along with Political Science and Corporate Strategies. Abigail is particularly interested in campus politics and national politics. Besides writing for the Vanderbilt Political Review, Abigail is a involved in Kappa Delta Sorority and Vanderbilt Protecting Animal Welfare Society (Vandy Paws).

  • John Deere Service Manuals#1

    April 18, 2019

    you’re soooo gifted on paper. God is really utilizing you in great ways. You are carrying out a superb work! It was an excellent blog!

  • Emmett#2

    April 12, 2019

    I have actually been seeking blogs where blog owner covers penis augmentation or at the very least delves into the topic of penis enlargement with an independent and also major voice. What are the leading blog sites of this kind?.

  • Ronald#3

    April 10, 2019

    Hi there. I was just wondering why its such a big thing these days to have a ridiculous amount of ram in a computer? People tell me that the more Ram you have in your computer the faster your computer will be. I always thought that it was the processor that controls the speed of a computer and not the Ram.. . I had 512MB of Ram in my laptop and I have now changed it to 2Gigs of Ram and I’ve seen no difference in performance what so ever. . Could somebody please explain to me what does Ram does exactly?. Thanks in advance.

  • this guy#4

    April 8, 2019

    What are Mark Zuckerberg’s blog posts in the movie “The Social Network”?

  • John Deere Repair Manuals#5

    April 8, 2019

    The the next time I just read a blog, I am hoping who’s doesnt disappoint me around that one. After all, It was my solution to read, but I just thought youd have some thing interesting to convey. All I hear is often a lot of whining about something that you could fix should you werent too busy seeking attention.

  • John Deere Diagnostic and Test Manuals#6

    April 8, 2019

    of course we need to know our family history so that we can share it to our kids..

  • John Deere Diagnostic and Test Manuals#7

    April 6, 2019

    Hello! I would wish to give a enormous thumbs up to the wonderful information you may have here about this post. I will be returning to your blog site to get more detailed soon.

  • article#8

    April 3, 2019

    I just want to mention I am beginner to weblog and absolutely liked you’re page. Very likely I’m likely to bookmark your website . You definitely come with exceptional article content. Kudos for sharing your webpage.

  • yeezy#9

    January 11, 2019

    My husband and i were quite fulfilled when Louis could finish off his inquiry through your precious recommendations he grabbed out of the weblog. It is now and again perplexing just to possibly be releasing points which often other folks might have been trying to sell. And we also figure out we’ve got the blog owner to appreciate because of that. The specific explanations you’ve made, the straightforward site menu, the friendships your site make it easier to foster – it’s all amazing, and it’s leading our son and our family recognize that that theme is enjoyable, which is really indispensable. Many thanks for all!

  • nfl jerseys#10

    January 11, 2019

    Thank you a lot for providing individuals with an extremely nice opportunity to check tips from this website. It is usually very brilliant and packed with amusement for me and my office peers to visit your website nearly three times in 7 days to read the newest secrets you will have. Of course, we are usually impressed for the effective techniques you give. Certain 1 areas in this post are particularly the best we’ve had.

  • links of london sale#11

    January 10, 2019

    I precisely wanted to say thanks once again. I do not know what I would have implemented in the absence of the entire solutions contributed by you on such a field. It absolutely was a real frightening dilemma in my view, but finding out the very specialised fashion you managed the issue took me to jump over fulfillment. Now i’m grateful for this help and thus wish you find out what a great job you happen to be doing training some other people via your webpage. Probably you’ve never come across any of us.

  • yeezys#12

    January 9, 2019

    My wife and i ended up being fulfilled when Edward could do his research through your precious recommendations he got from your very own weblog. It’s not at all simplistic to just be handing out techniques that many some people have been selling. We really realize we have the website owner to thank for this. All of the explanations you’ve made, the easy web site navigation, the friendships you can make it possible to promote – it is most incredible, and it’s really aiding our son in addition to our family believe that this theme is satisfying, and that is seriously vital. Thank you for all the pieces!

  • outlet golden goose#13

    January 8, 2019

    Thank you so much for giving everyone a very terrific opportunity to check tips from here. It can be very pleasurable and stuffed with fun for me and my office colleagues to search your site particularly thrice per week to read through the fresh guidance you have got. And indeed, we’re usually pleased for the gorgeous ideas served by you. Selected two points on this page are really the best we have all had.

  • jordan retro#14

    January 7, 2019

    My spouse and i have been really fortunate that Michael could finish off his analysis using the precious recommendations he gained out of the blog. It’s not at all simplistic to just always be making a gift of secrets which a number of people could have been trying to sell. We really acknowledge we have you to give thanks to for this. The specific explanations you have made, the easy blog menu, the friendships you help engender – it is all awesome, and it is letting our son and the family reason why this concept is excellent, and that is wonderfully serious. Many thanks for all!

  • yeezy boost#15

    January 5, 2019

    Thanks so much for giving everyone a very splendid chance to read from this web site. It is usually very cool plus packed with amusement for me personally and my office colleagues to search your web site particularly 3 times in 7 days to read the new things you will have. And of course, we’re certainly contented with the astounding tricks you serve. Some 3 areas in this article are completely the simplest we have all had.

  • off white clothing#16

    January 4, 2019

    I wish to express my appreciation for your kindness supporting individuals that actually need help on this important field. Your very own commitment to passing the solution across has been astonishingly beneficial and have specifically helped some individuals much like me to arrive at their targets. Your new informative help implies much a person like me and substantially more to my colleagues. Thank you; from each one of us.

  • golden goose sneakers#17

    January 4, 2019

    I in addition to my guys happened to be reading through the nice key points from the blog and so immediately I got a terrible feeling I had not thanked the blog owner for them. My young boys had been consequently glad to study them and have seriously been using those things. Appreciate your getting considerably kind as well as for deciding on variety of impressive information most people are really eager to be informed on. My personal sincere regret for not expressing appreciation to you sooner.

  • air jordan#18

    January 3, 2019

    I truly wanted to make a quick message so as to thank you for those lovely advice you are showing on this website. My extensive internet research has at the end been compensated with beneficial suggestions to go over with my colleagues. I would believe that we website visitors actually are very much lucky to dwell in a really good network with very many lovely professionals with very helpful basics. I feel somewhat blessed to have seen your entire weblog and look forward to tons of more awesome minutes reading here. Thank you once again for everything.

  • air jodan 6#19

    January 2, 2019

    My husband and i felt really fulfilled when Albert managed to carry out his researching by way of the precious recommendations he grabbed through your blog. It is now and again perplexing to just continually be giving out tips and tricks which often many others may have been selling. Therefore we already know we have the blog owner to give thanks to because of that. The explanations you made, the simple blog navigation, the friendships your site make it easier to instill – it’s most powerful, and it’s really assisting our son and our family do think this concept is exciting, and that is particularly fundamental. Thanks for the whole thing!

  • yeezy 500 blush#20

    January 1, 2019

    Thanks a lot for giving everyone an extraordinarily remarkable chance to read in detail from this web site. It can be very enjoyable plus jam-packed with amusement for me and my office peers to search your website not less than 3 times in a week to learn the latest tips you have got. And indeed, I am usually motivated concerning the mind-boggling points you serve. Selected 1 points in this article are particularly the most beneficial we’ve ever had.

  • AFH#21

    November 10, 2016

    This election was full of wins for Gary Johnson and the Libertarian Party. While major media continues to concentrate only on the establishment candidates and their shenanigans, the LP has made history for itself. 17 states surrendered ballot access where previously the Democrats and Republicans had passed election laws to try and keep third parties out of the race. This will mean that they can save millions of dollars in following elections. Money that once went to the task of having to qualify our candidates can now be used for promoting them. If you voted for Johnson, know this: Your voice sounded more loudly toward positive change than any vote cast for Hillary or Trump.

    A map of the wins that the Libertarian Party picked up this year can be found on this app written by a two Libertarian Millennial volunteers election eve who wanted to watch the effects of their hard work:


Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *