The Carol Swain petition hurts the cause more than it helps. But there’s a better way.

The Carol Swain petition hurts the cause more than it helps. But there’s a better way.

391 views

The controversial Carol Swain, a Vanderbilt Professor, is once again in the news after almost 1,500 students (and counting) signed a petition to have her fired.  (The demand was recently downgraded to suspension and mandatory diversity training).  According to the petition’s authors, Swain is intolerant towards non-Christians and the LGBTQI community, thus misrepresenting the University and making some students feel unsafe.  Unfortunately, the authors of the petition and all those who signed it will end up hurting their cause more than helping it. 

I won’t defend Swain with the hackneyed argument that, as a University, we benefit from a diversity of opinions.  What this argument really means is that we benefit from a diversity of opinions as long as those opinions are within reason.  For example, imagine a professor with a habit of using the N-word or denying the Holocaust.  Would anyone really argue that the university benefits from this professors opinions?  Of course not.  The question is where is the line between tolerable and intolerable speech, and has Swain crossed it? 

There’s no objective way to know this.  Swain has certainly spoken insensitively, and, in my view, incorrectly, about Muslims and the LGBTQI community.  In my perfect world, nobody would share her views.  However, in the real world many people do.  In fact, many of her views are consistent with the positions of a major political party in this country, one with control of both Houses of Congress, most state senates, and most governorships.  For instance, gay marriage only recently became accepted by a majority of Americans, and many proposals for increasing the rights of the transgendered are still opposed by the majority. Living in this liberal enclave called Vanderbilt University, we might forget that certain ideas we call “bigoted” are simply called “conservative” by a majority or large minority of Americans.  So, if Carol Swain and people like her make you feel unsafe at Vanderbilt, I’ve got some very bad news—the rest of the country is way worse. 

That doesn’t make it right, of course.  As I was recently reminded, most of the country once approved of slavery.  We may one day look at those who deny LGBTQI people their rights with the same disdain as we look upon the segregationists in our history books.  I believe that human society has, in general, become more and more tolerant with time, and, if we want that to continue, we must work for it.  But the best way to do that is not to jettison people like Carol Swain.  Doing so creates a resentful divide, fuels the culture war, and eliminates the possibility that those people will ever be convinced.  Plus, firing Carol Swain would give her more of a platform, and ammunition, to espouse her opinions.  I believe Fox News would pick her up in a heartbeat, as she is already a frequent guest. 

Universities should be concerned with the psychological well-being of their students.  The hot trend these days is to lambast colleges for “coddling” students, but I’m not jumping on that bandwagon.  Colleges should, to some degree, model the way society should be, and society should treat people equally.  But there has to be a balance between modeling an ideal society and preparing students for the real one.  Vanderbilt, and other socially liberal communities, should be wary of severing ties with social conservatives.  It may be uncomfortable, but the only way to reach that ideal society is to slowly win them over through dialogue and reason.  That can’t happen if we quarantine ourselves inside bubbles of tolerance.  I don’t want to criticize the authors or signees of the study.  It’s easy for me, as a white, cis-gendered, heterosexual man, to say, “let’s all just talk it out,” while others are victims of daily prejudice.  All I mean to do is suggest an alternative.  There is a social phenomenon called the “echo chamber,” which means that when people with similar views are placed in a closed system, they tend to reinforce their own beliefs and insulate themselves from those who disagree.  By sorting into groups of like-minded people, Americans have gradually been sorting themselves into these echo chambers.  This petition, and other attempts to shun those like Swain, only aids that sorting process, thereby strengthening the echo chamber and making the divide harder to cross.  If we are interested in creating a fair and equal society, we’d be better off keeping Swain, and those sympathetic to her, close enough to reach.  Don’t sign the petition.  Reason, compassion, and some time will work better than a petition ever could. 

About author

Alexander Slawson

Alex Slawson is the Editor-in-Chief of the Vanderbilt Political Review. A senior majoring in political science and economics, Alex is passionate about writing and public policy.

Comments
  • 릴 게임#1

    May 16, 2019

    just your articles? I mean, what you say is important and all.

    Reply
  • Latest news#2

    May 7, 2019

    I really liked your blog article. Want more.

    Reply
  • Vans Romania Originale#3

    April 27, 2019

    Really informative blog.Much thanks again. Keep writing.

    Reply
  • adidasi tommy hilfiger#4

    April 27, 2019

    You are my inspiration, I have few web logs and often run out from brand . Truth springs from argument amongst friends. by David Hume.

    Reply
  • prostitutki chelyabinska#5

    April 27, 2019

    It as best to take part in a contest for one of the best blogs on the web. I will recommend this web site!

    Reply
  • paul george shoes#6

    April 27, 2019

    I simply wanted to thank you very much once more. I do not know the things that I could possibly have gone through without the type of concepts shown by you relating to this theme. It was before an absolute frightful crisis in my view, however , taking a look at the very expert avenue you treated it forced me to leap with gladness. I’m just grateful for the service as well as sincerely hope you really know what a powerful job that you are getting into training the others with the aid of your blog. I’m certain you have never got to know all of us.

    Reply
  • small business entrepreneurship#7

    April 26, 2019

    I will immediately grasp your rss as I can at in finding your e-mail subscription link or e-newsletter service. Do you ave any? Please let me know so that I could subscribe. Thanks.

    Reply
  • small business for dummies#8

    April 26, 2019

    important site Of course, you are not using some Under-developed place, The united kingdom possesses high water-purification benchmarks

    Reply
  • Ferdinand#9

    April 25, 2019

    What is the most convenient method to duplicate my WordPress blogs to a brand-new hosting company?

    Reply
  • chocopie#10

    April 22, 2019

    PxvSY4 You have made some decent points there. I checked on the internet for more information about the issue and found most individuals will go along with your views on this web site.

    Reply
  • Teresia#11

    April 19, 2019

    What are the very best internet sites and blogs devoted to reading and also literary works?

    Reply
  • John Deere Service Manuals#12

    April 18, 2019

    i really hate it when my sebaceous gland are producing too much oil, it really makes my life miserable,

    Reply
  • Celesta#13

    April 12, 2019

    Exactly how does one generate income from blog sites? How does one tackle it or begin it?

    Reply
  • Tractor Workshop Manuals#14

    April 10, 2019

    You need to be a part of a contest for example of the most useful blogs online. I am going to suggest this web site!

    Reply
  • Micheal#15

    April 10, 2019

    How can I personalize my blog without making it look like crap?

    Reply
  • websites#16

    April 8, 2019

    How do I copyright the content on my web site?

    Reply
  • John Deere Diagnostic and Test Manuals#17

    April 6, 2019

    bad credits can happen at any point in your life so be prepared to always get some extra income,

    Reply
  • blog here#18

    April 2, 2019

    I just want to say I am beginner to blogging and site-building and absolutely enjoyed your blog. Very likely I’m want to bookmark your blog post . You certainly come with good articles and reviews. Regards for sharing your web page.

    Reply
  • Ghetto Investor#19

    February 21, 2016

    Noted: Lots of pathetic self-flagellation in the latter part of your article.

    Seriously, you get credit for acceding that Swain has a right to speak. Many of the fascist, liberal nazis of tolerance that infest Vandy’s halls won’t. It’s a start, but the University is seriously broken and until there is a movement that supports divergent opinions (that differ from the faculty) and challenges the status-quo you are without hope.

    Reply
  • Mik Sacul (@NottaLiberal)#20

    November 13, 2015

    If you are so concerned with the well being of students as you claim, why are you teaching them about Saul Alinsky? Why do you allow a culture of binge drinking and sexual exploitation? You don’t give a crap about anyone UNLESS they are Liberal. Just like Hillary, YOU ARE A NO GOOD LIAR and this country would be better off without people like you!

    Reply
  • Anon#21

    November 12, 2015

    Transgender and incorrect use of “begs the question” but you tried.

    Reply
  • Erin#22

    November 12, 2015

    Hmmmm

    Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *