Vanderbilt Professors Share Their Thoughts on Safe Spaces

Vanderbilt Professors Share Their Thoughts on Safe Spaces


In late August, University of Chicago Dean of Students John Ellison sent a letter to the incoming class of 2020 making clear that the university does agree with recent trends in academia. The letter reads,“Our commitment to academic freedom means that we do not support so-called ‘trigger warnings,’ we do not cancel invited speakers because their topics might prove controversial, and we do not condone the creation of intellectual ‘safe spaces’ where individuals can retreat from ideas and perspectives at odds with their own.”

Speech on college campus has become a point of debate in recent years. Many protests have broken out due to the opinions of guest speakers. In late 2015, a Yale University faculty member defended free speech, arguing that the administration ought not tell students how to dress on Halloween. Student backlash eventually led to the professors in question stepping down. At the University of Missouri, President Tim Wolfe was forced to step down after protests by students and the school’s football team. This issue will once again take center stage at Vanderbilt on October 11th when conservative activist and Breitbart editor Milo Yiannopoulos comes campus .

The University of Chicago letter has garnered a predictably mixed response from academic leaders across the country, and at Vanderbilt we see a similar trend. In our interview, political science and law professor Carol Swain expressed support for the letter and hoped that more universities will choose to follow the University of Chicago’s example. She believes that safe spaces are “unnecessary and send the wrong message to students” and that “students should be mature enough to engage in conversations on issues and ideas that may be foreign to them without taking offense.” Over email correspondence, Richard Pitt, a professor of sociology at Vanderbilt, mostly agreed with the Chicago letter and is glad that the institution “isn’t buckling to what sometimes feels like a left-leaning corollary to the censorship and intellectual witch-hunts I’ve felt from cultural/ political forces on the right.” On the issue of safe spaces, Pitt expresses a nuanced point of view, writing, “I want my classes to be spaces that are safe FOR important (and sometimes uncomfortable) conversations, not spaces that are safe FROM them.” [Emphasis his.]

Professor Pitt’s comments get to the heart of some of the disagreement concerning the University of Chicago letter. Slate’s LV Anderson writes that Dean Ellison completely mischaracterizes the point of safe spaces, arguing that they exist primarily to help accomplish Ellison’s goal of “building a campus that welcomes people of all backgrounds.” One layer of agreement found in all analyses is that debates with people of differing viewpoints often enrich student experiences. Vanderbilt first-year Dylan Reilly commented, “[One] issue is that people think opinions should be treated as facts, and I think safe spaces and trigger warnings are important because that’s not how opinions should work.” Furthermore, Professor Swain recognized the importance in learning how to get along with those who may have different opinions and personal backgrounds, arguing, “The whole purpose of affirmative action is for us to learn from one another.” Professor Pitt argues further that “too often once [students] get to campus, they only value the diversity as long as it doesn’t make them uncomfortable by being ‘too different.’ Give me a Black roommate, but none of the ‘Black Lives Matter’ activism. Give me a roommate from Alabama, but she better embrace my being a lesbian on day one.”

Another notable nuance in this issue is the idea of one instructor’s bias affecting the type of “trigger-warning” given in the classroom. As The Atlantic’s Conor Friedersdorf writes, “The myth of the value-neutral trigger warning is most easily punctured by imagining how a typical college professor would react to a request from an evangelical conservative student that The Vagina Monologues carry a trigger warning for ‘discussion of female genitalia.’” The regulation of one’s own biases is much more of an art than a science and is a practice that must continually require introspection. Professor Pitt acknowledges, “I’ve been accused of being against Christianity and too-pro-religious, racist against White students and ‘not-woke’ by Black students…in the same semester, in the same course.” What makes college campuses so unique is that they allow students to discuss each other’s biases immediately in a classroom setting, a far cry from reading an online article or watching a newscast where the viewer has no effective way to retort. Therefore, it is essential that such discussion continue, a goal that all sides of the safe-space and trigger warning debate hold.  

Ellison’s letter says that one of the University of Chicago’s defining characteristics is “commitment to freedom of inquiry and expression.” As a leading national institution, the University of Chicago has prepared students to excel in life after college for more than one hundred years. Thus, the administration framed the letter in a manner that leads the reader to assume safe-spaces and trigger-warnings inhibit the achievement of such excellence. As Professor Swain states, “If you have a student and all they know is safe-spaces, microaggressions, and the search for trigger warnings, when they go out into the real world, be it a job or in the military, the world doesn’t operate that way.” However, a different interpretation of these ideas could lead to the conclusion that only in “safe spaces” are people of all backgrounds comfortable to engage in critical dialogue. A supporter of safe-spaces, Reilly stated, “If your opinion is right and just, you should be able to have it challenged and you can defend it.”

What I have gleaned from these interviews is the fact that whether or not one is pro-safe space or pro-trigger warning, cultivating a campus where many opinions are tolerated is the ideal. One should not respond to a sincere opinion with hostility but rather with measured disagreement. Anytime someone feels marginalized or not respected due to an ideology or personal history, the system is not working. Going forward, campuses must identify the right mixture of respecting divergent opinions and supporting those individuals and groups who feel overlooked. To conclude in the words of Professor Pitt, “Hopefully, the tolerance and openness-to-change that characterizes this current generation of college students (according to practically every survey of you folks) can lead to more open-and-honest conversations.”

About author

Simon Silverberg

Simon Silverberg is a senior from Baton Rouge, Louisiana. He intends to major in Public Policy and considers himself a certified American history nerd. Like many, his interest in politics was sparked by the Presidential election of 2008. He participated in his high school's student government, interned for a Louisiana Governor's race campaign, and is also a Stambaugh RA. Simon is particularly interested in the areas of international trade policy, environmental regulation and political rhetoric. His favorite Twitter personalities include Nate Silver, Colin Cowherd, and Keith Olbermann. Though from the deep South, Simon is an avid New York Mets fan (it's a long story).

  • 토토 사이트#1

    May 12, 2019

    Pretty! This was an incredibly wonderful post. Thanks for supplying this info.

  • collegian#2

    April 26, 2019

    Really informative blog.Much thanks again. Fantastic.

  • kingdom karaoke#3

    April 26, 2019

    sky vegas mobile view of Three Gorges | Wonder Travel Blog

  • Charles#4

    April 24, 2019

    What is the best software to make web sites and blogs?

  • i love pron#5

    April 22, 2019

    AQIqhB This is one awesome article post.Thanks Again. Really Cool.

  • Russ#6

    April 20, 2019

    I would really like to make a blog site yet. I’m not exactly sure what sort of blog sites obtain one of the most website traffic? What sort of blog sites do you browse? I mainly surf picture blog sites and also style blogs. Just getting a poll right here many thanks!.

  • John Deere Technical Manuals#7

    April 18, 2019

    The way you write, you are really a professional blogger.~’*.’

  • Ashlea#8

    April 12, 2019

    I’m wanting to look at blog sites consisting of music I such as, however looking via all the separated, outdated and also crap blog sites is a headache. I understand there are hundreds of blog sites, exists a good source to seek out the preferred ones?.

  • John Deere Diagnostic and Test Manuals#9

    April 10, 2019

    choice. Anyhow; if you are a young driver and new to the road life, then you can certainly horn

  • Aubrey#10

    April 9, 2019

    In Firefox – How to open in new tab automatically when I click a bookmark?

  • John Deere Service Manuals#11

    April 9, 2019

    I’m impressed, I have to admit. Actually rarely can i encounter a weblog that’s both educative and entertaining, and without a doubt, you might have hit the nail around the head. Your concept is outstanding; ab muscles a thing that too few individuals are speaking intelligently about. We are delighted i stumbled across this inside my seek out something with this.

  • visit this page#12

    April 8, 2019

    I cut a movie into 10 minute parts and uploaded to youtube, i only had uploaded two parts by the time i got a copyright notice. How can i upload movies without it getting deleted?.

  • Tractor Workshop Manuals#13

    April 7, 2019

    This site can be a walk-through its the information you wanted concerning this and didn’t know who to ask. Glimpse here, and you’ll undoubtedly discover it.

  • Tractor Workshop Manuals#14

    April 6, 2019

    certainly like your website but you have to check the spelling on several of your posts. Many of them are rife with spelling issues and I find it very troublesome to tell the reality however I will certainly come again again.

  • content#15

    April 3, 2019

    I simply want to tell you that I am just new to blogs and definitely loved your blog site. Most likely I’m likely to bookmark your blog post . You actually have remarkable posts. Thanks a bunch for revealing your web page.

  • BJ Crowell#16

    November 19, 2016

    What the hell is wrong with the millennial generation??? They don’t understand politics in the real world, they think being social means getting on Twitter or Facebook but not talking to people face-to-face like adults. I think it’s time to have the discussion that may be the millennial generation needs to be engaged in a way that correct the problem. Terms like “triggered” and “safe space” have defined an entire generation of people based on nothing more than their willful ignorance and misconceptions about real-world issues. They need to be taught that there is a way to deal with these particular subjects without it becoming a social justice issue.


Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *