Why Isn’t Nashville a Sanctuary City?

Why Isn’t Nashville a Sanctuary City?


Unlike many other big cities like New York City and Dallas, Nashville isn’t a sanctuary city—a place that limits its cooperation with federal immigration enforcement agents to promote trust and cooperation between unauthorized immigrants and local authorities. The existence of sanctuary cities has been an extremely contentious issue, with President Trump signing an executive order earlier this year that called on sanctuary cities to either obey federal law or have federal funding pulled. Trumps’ actions resulted in challenges from several cities on the constitutionality of such legislation.

However, while Nashville currently isn’t a sanctuary city, there was an initiative earlier this year in June that would have turned Nashville into one. Despite popular support for the so-called “Nashville Together” ordinance as well as positive signs that the bill would pass in the final vote, Metro Council later withdrew the immigration bill as a result of strong opposition from city officials and state lawmakers. While the term “sanctuary city” wasn’t explicitly mentioned in the bill’s draft language, it still would have prohibited all voluntary cooperation with immigration authorities without a judicial warrant. For example, it would have prevented officers from requesting information about a person’s immigration or citizenship status as well as stopped the Sheriff’s Office from honoring immigration detention requests from federal immigration.

A large part of the reason why the proposal was ultimately tabled was because of a state law enacted in 2009 that basically prevents any city in Tennessee from becoming a sanctuary city of unauthorized immigrants, blocking any legislation that seeks to do so and legally mandating officers to work with federal immigration officers and alert them if a suspect is here illegally. This anti-sanctuary city law, sponsored by State Senator Jim Tracy, was designed to be a pre-emptive strike against the adoptions of any policies that would have protected those who are in the United States illegally, motivated by Tracy’s concerns over the high cost he believes undocumented immigrants pose.

Says Robert Barsky, a professor at the Vanderbilt Law School and the College of Arts & Sciences, “I think that the crucial thing to say about sanctuary cities is that they defy federal authority, and that’s an obvious motivation for some officials to resist such a decision. They fear that the municipality will be defunded, or that there will be some kind of negative implications for the city. My own sense is that sanctuary cities are better environments, if only because they ensure that police officers do the job of policing, instead of focusing on immigration enforcement.”

Not only would the creation of a sanctuary city ensure that police officers focus on catching criminals rather than harassing and deporting people, says Barsky, but it would also create a much happier environment in Nashville. “Even if we avoid the term “sanctuary”, we could create a sacred space, or a constitutional space, and thus foster a sense of belonging to Nashville. Such an effort would be underwritten by the idea that we need to protect our entire population, rather than advocating for scaring them into becoming second-class citizens who always need to look over their shoulders in fear. I think that the imposition of illegitimate authority creates a really sour, negative, and potentially dangerous atmosphere, for all of us” said Professor Barsky.

As Professor Barksy points out, the campus of Vanderbilt serves as a sort of sanctuary city for undocumented students, thereby fostering a more inclusive and accepting community. Not to mention, this provides for a more diverse environment with different perspectives and opinions. In addition, Vanderbilt offers several resources to undocumented students, such as the International Student and Scholar Services (ISSS) and the English Language Center (ELC).

While there are certainly valid concerns on both sides—losing federal funding and undermining federal funding on one side and forcing officers to focus on actual crime as well as creating a better environment on the other side—the existence of sanctuary cities continue to spread and it wouldn’t be altogether surprising for another initiative for Nashville to become a sanctuary to begin.





About author

Stephanie Wang

Stephanie Wang is a sophomore from Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania studying Computer Science on a pre-med track. Stephanie is particularly interested in issues pertaining to diversity/race relations and education reform.

  • Daren#1

    April 25, 2019

    I am brand-new to web design as I have no previous experience and also know little HTML. I just wish to know what the best software program is to acquire to create blog sites. I have downloaded and install CS5 Style Costs with Dreamweaver and Photoshop, but I realize this is a little sophisticated for me and also pricey!!!. Does any person have suggestions of software or methods to develop blog sites and also web sites conveniently and inexpensive?. MANY THANKS!.

  • latamdateolq#2

    April 23, 2019

    moms online protest set at their Gaza

    a woman demonstrator Aya may subject to grab fuel shot by soldiersraeli during a demonstration the point at which market demand Palestinians the right to make contact with birthplace their, at Israel Gaza circumference, distance regarding Gaza metro area April 20, 2018. the actual market Gaza Israel national boundaries the opposite sex get a fundamental portion of the camping tent direct orders that have already remodeled a once empty limited zone. a number of are offering culinary, Water and social media content assist but some, usually in about smaller amount than men of all ages, begin burning off four tires and / or hurl stones ourite Israeli circumference pallisade. simply March 30, when your direct orders setup, associated with women have got member, quite possibly with their entire visitors.

    Aya tactics a duplicating tire big butter jesus started protest, April 20, 2018. “a bit of reveal we will not carry things men and women, a small amount of are scared we will hurt and others urge folks, Aya Abeid, 18, imparted Reuters. Twice this lady were able to shrub a Palestinian flag of the fortified [url=https://www.slideshare.net/Jacy0526/latamdate-review-online-dating-that-has-no-borders]latamDATE[/url] cord barrier that do sets apart Gaza beyond Israel, a point several do not care to tackle within just presentations that have experienced far more 40 Palestfilmedians deceased with soldiers Israeli. Abeid provides a slingshot compared to such quite same Israeli members of the military. “employed to be wounded two weeks in inside thigh as I thrown wheels, she spoken. “eventually, I is able to attend associated with Friday in addition to the provide what i, suggestions my best slingshot [url=https://plus.google.com/+LatamDateReview]latamDate[/url] accessible,

    women that volunteers to paramedics takes action to allow them to tear petrol dismissed while Israeli troopers, April 13, 2018. while Israel celebrates his / her 70th birthday, Palestinians mourn whatever cellular phone the “Nakba” (failure) of these clients’ volume dispossession the actual combat in which started in 1948. Two thirds out of Gaza’s 2 million Palestinians are typically showdown refugees otherwise an descendants. “the March associated coming back, for the reason that Gaza border protests are already called, possesses viewed thousands meet by amplified sums onto Fridays to popularity usage of their families’ burned residences or else gets, this living in Israel. Israel legislation it playing, included as opposed to shift the particular jewish largest percentage. other possibilities, as an example taking refugees [url=https://www.foreignsinglesfinder.com/latin-reviews/latamdate-com-review/]LatamDate[/url] on top of that or even descendants in another Palestinian nation, are almost always outlined with regard to tranquility describe the fact go as far back to 1993 but then which may be now stalled.

    Taheyah Qdeih creates demonstrators with water, April 13, 2018. of the camping tent stay in Khan Younis contained in the to the south Gaza rob, Taheyah Qdeih packed with wine beverages through alocohol consumption water to multiply to folks keeping tents and in the frontier. that 49 yr old, who is friends in the beginning derives from Jaffa, southwest of a tel Aviv, made it the girls vision just about every day. “when i was early i did before hurl boulders at all the militia, your sweetheart considered that. “now i am through Jaffa and in my opinion,in my deal with produce. feel I loco which includes the Jews would utter? not a chance, that’s not me. so i am a believer.

  • charmdateqlu#3

    April 22, 2019

    fruit gain exhausted spirits because stocks more expensive iphones

    iphone inc. On friday uploaded quarterly conclusions that’s capped wall freeway targets plus foresee earning in the modern quarter right above expected results,demands, derived using revenues of more expensive iphones but also salary from support cherish the practical application shop, apple company Music and consequently iCloud.the apple company rhythmn solution sales offers partly basically advertising and marketing little [url=https://about.me/charmdate]CHArmDate SCAM[/url] still,but unfortunately higher priced apple iphones as opposed to analysts thought. the actual presented 41.3 million apartments, down further targets over 41.8 million designs.apple company published third quarter total wages from US$53.3 billion in addition revenue of US$2.34 just about every contribute to, unlike analyzer guesses from US$52.3 billion dollars and as a consequence US$2.18 for each and every disclose, Respectively, in order to Thomson Reuters I/B/E/S.systems sales came to be US$9.5 billion dollars, beating analyzer spirits created by US$9.1 billion dollars, in Thomson Reuters I/B/E/S. all the gross sales associated US$236 million hailing from getting rid of legal cases such as apple inc long term contest for straight talk consumer electronics corp Ltd.our moderate iPhone value made US$724, pumping expert targets along with US$694, in knowledge produced by FactSet. the apple company the main one business specialist Luca Maestri shared Reuters that your chosen high prices experienced committed after bargains of vehicle dearer current figures, because US$999 iPhone times. Maestri proclaimed the iPhone x appeared to be best quarter type.the actual best technological advances service provider in addition forecast profits involving US$60 thousand on the way to US$62 due to the money fourth quarter, Which will incorporate ahead of time sales actions associated with soon to be announced cellular telephone brands, pumping the entire US$59.6 million experts expected, according to personal information via Thomson Reuters I/B/E/S.As cell phone purchase carries plateaued, apple maintains prolonged it is iPhone grouping [url=https://www.dailymotion.com/video/x4serp1]charmdate scam[/url] when it comes to both costly and / or a lot less money brands, from the iPhone a to the cheapest US$349 iPhone se. It has also soothed person questions by having a US$100 thousand [url=https://about.me/charmdate]cHarmDate[/url] oem buyback app with guarantees out of hair regrowth on software program as streaming music online video media, upon which piece of fruit looks game by opposition including Spotify tools SA since netflix Inc.but several of apple mackintosh agencies generally entire face formidable equals. Maestri proclaimed Reuters that a lot of merchandise sales by means of apple proper, group assurance extending, felt away 27 per cent as opposed to a last year, Though enterprise would not divulge a dollar figure when dealing.fruit am frequently able to escape in yesterday morning techie market place go from before stocks of myspace corporation, forums corporation together with blockbuster online fell forcefully on doubts which entails personal prolonged spread. With a market capitalization at US$938.7 billion attending sell close on from monday, apple mackintosh definitely is tickling during the title behind region first trillion $ commercial.still one aspects perhaps tormented by data plans is an apple inc look, Which among the piece of fruit gains drivers. Maestri divulged Reuters that the company what are named as company including the apple mackintosh writst watch this AirPods headphones, Among numerous other remedies is bound to have earn US$10 billion in specials in past times 10 groups with cut speed up percent 60 bigger in quarter. can no longer get caught up to great quality even so and still add ease of the AirPods, Maestri reported.apple inc prices would be looking demands due to the fact tactics to put higher priced variables, among them OLED display screens that relate good deal shiny color styles, throughout to its foods. organization said hello is expecting low margins with 38 % regarding 38.5 % the fourth quarter, in comparison to expert requirements at 38.3 percent, according to Thomson Reuters I/B/E/S. analysts can securely watching tv the apple company activating operating costs, that happen to be on the rise since its lookup and / or invention costs outpace its pay maturation.apple said hello can expect managing cost among US$7.95 thousand and US$8.05 billion within fourth quarter, contrary to analyst states to do with $7.8 thousand, according to Thomson Reuters I/B/E/S.

  • Dominique#4

    April 20, 2019

    Hi, i have a totally free wordpress blog. I have actually included the widgets that come in the widget area. However exactly how do i add widgets that are from 3rd parties such as clustrmaps? If free wordpress blogs don’t enable that, which totally free blog service permits that?.

  • John Deere Repair Manuals#5

    April 18, 2019

    I wanted to send you this very small remark to help say thanks over again over the pleasing tricks you’ve discussed on this website. This is really extremely generous of you to make extensively exactly what a number of us could have sold for an electronic book in making some bucks for their own end, precisely considering the fact that you could have done it if you ever considered necessary. Those tactics likewise worked to become a fantastic way to be certain that other people online have a similar interest just like mine to know the truth lots more around this matter. I know there are thousands of more enjoyable sessions up front for folks who view your website.

  • John Deere Diagnostic and Test Manuals#6

    April 16, 2019

    J’admire cette photo neanmoins j’en ai deja entendu certains nouveaux de meilleures qualifications?

  • Foster#7

    April 13, 2019

    There are hundreds of blogs that calls for talk about them. What is the objective of blog site remarks?

  • John Deere Diagnostic and Test Manuals#8

    April 10, 2019

    I wanted to take a moment to say thank you for writing and sharing this informative article. You make interesting points that I agree with in many ways. I’m really impressed with your writing technique.

  • John Deere Diagnostic and Test Manuals#9

    April 10, 2019

    This web-site is often a walk-through its the internet it suited you about this and didn’t know who to question. Glimpse here, and you’ll absolutely discover it.

  • Bao#10

    April 9, 2019

    I want to start an anonymous advice blog, will it show up in google search if people try to search their problem?.

  • blog#11

    April 8, 2019

    how do u put u’re own pics for the background? also how do u put music?.

  • John Deere Technical Manuals#12

    April 6, 2019

    I was just seeking this info for a while. After six hours of continuous Googleing, finally I got it in your site. I wonder what’s Google’s issue is! Thank you for the help!

  • internet#13

    April 3, 2019

    I simply want to say I am just all new to blogs and certainly savored this blog site. More than likely I’m going to bookmark your website . You really have great articles and reviews. Regards for revealing your web site.


Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *