Stop the SNAP Judgements

Stop the SNAP Judgements


It started with the election debates, disappeared for a few months, and now it’s back: the argument over the future of SNAP has resumed.

This past Thursday, the Republican led House voted to cut food stamps. The vote split cleanly among party lines and drew outrage from Democrats in the House and Senate. Pelosi accused the bill of “preying” on the poor at a time when one in seven Americans rely on SNAP benefits. At the same time, Republicans such as Frank Lucas hailed the bill for its “common sense reforms.” Kevin Cramer of North Dakota went as far as to say the bill would end a “culture of permanent dependency,” and others cited reports of abuse in the system.

Recently, in addition to the political debate, the use and abuse of food stamps was brought to national attention. Fox News detailed the SNAP usage of Jason Greenslate, a 28 year old surfer from California who uses food stamps as “free food” as he works on his career as a musician. His case draws criticism from both sides of the aisle. Democrats point out that his case is not the typical one. About 75% of households using SNAP have children, and several more support seniors or disabled members. Greenslate is one of the 10% who are able bodied adults without dependents using SNAP, a number that has risen from prerecession times.

Obviously, SNAP has flaws. Greenslate is not the perfect case of a household on food stamps. Additionally, the government has tracked and fought SNAP fraud since 1993.

However, SNAP’s flaws are arguably disproportionate to the ire they draw in debates. Over the past two decades, fraud has fallen from about four cents a dollar to one to two cents a dollar. The USDA continues to investigate fraud cases and tighten its standards. Furthermore, Greenslate is a single anecdote of the 10% of food stamp cases he belongs to. His story illustrates abuse of the program, but then consider Jason Kirell’s story. Following the Fox report, the Huffington Post highlighted Kirell, a 35 year old army veteran. He’s worked since he was 17, served in the military in Afghanistan, and has been unemployed and looking for work since June. Food stamps provide him temporary relief as he tries to return to work.

Kirell is the anti-Greenslate, but just as Greenslate’s anecdote does not mean SNAP should be ended, Kirell’s story does not mean SNAP should be expanded. There is economic evidence for the existence of SNAP, but there is also economic evidence against government spending. From these standpoints, statistics form the best basis of an argument. Trying to find the right balance of SNAP funding and forming the rules of usage should be based on what works the best for the most amount of people—a task much more difficult than finding a welfare queen or the “deserving” poor.

Despite this, the debate over food stamps often depends on these anecdotes. Everyone has stories—the welfare queen buying crab legs and birthday cake, the friend of a friend who has fallen on hard times—and everyone has strong feelings about them. Both serve their purpose, but only to illustrate the greater economic debate over the efficiency of welfare. Using these examples as a basis for argument will not get our country anywhere: words cannot solve the problems of statistics.

Image from


About author

Alison Shanahan

Alison is an economics and psychology major from Saint Paul, Minnesota. She spent last summer working on a local campaign and interning with an activist nonprofit. Her main political interests are the economic analysis of public policy, particularly when it relates to poverty, education, and the environment.

  • Solomon#1

    April 20, 2019

    What are some good sites as well as blog sites for inexpensive fashion for grownups?

  • John Deere Service Manuals#2

    April 18, 2019

    Considerably, the particular post is truly the greatest with this deserving subject. To be sure together with your results and also can easily thirstily look forward to Your own potential improvements. Simply just declaring thank you will, no doubt not simply just be sufficient, for your wonderful quality within your writing. I will immediately grab your rss to remain up to date with any kind of updates. Real perform as well as much success inside your company dealings!

  • John Deere Service Manuals#3

    April 15, 2019

    I admire this article for the well-researched content and excellent wording. I got so involved in this material that I couldn’t stop reading. I am impressed with your work and skill. Thank you so much.

  • Son#4

    April 12, 2019

    What hosting websites will permit my blog site to earn money off adds being positioned on my blog site?

  • Eric#5

    April 11, 2019

    Copyright? I want to gather stories/articles from the web and put them onto one page?

  • Tractor Workshop Manuals#6

    April 11, 2019

    Fishing season is coming up! Love reading through all aspects of it Thanks for keeping us updated, fantastic study!

  • Dolly#7

    April 10, 2019

    I have seen a lot of blogs in blogspot. What purpose do they serve? Is it possible to make money through blogs. If yes how?.

  • John Deere Service Manuals#8

    April 10, 2019

    Some really fantastic info , Sword lily I noticed this.

  • John Deere Diagnostic and Test Manuals#9

    April 10, 2019

    Intriguing article. I understand I’m a little late in posting my comment though the article was to the point and the details I became trying to find. I can’t say that we agree with everything you could mentioned nevertheless it was emphatically fascinating! BTW…I found your web site through a Google search. I’m a frequent visitor on your blog all of which will return again soon.

  • go to this web-site#10

    April 8, 2019

    Can I share some links with copyright content on twitter?

  • John Deere Diagnostic and Test Manuals#11

    April 6, 2019

    You produced some decent points there. I looked online for that problem and located most people may go in conjunction with with your internet site.

  • More Bonuses#12

    April 4, 2019

    I simply want to mention I am new to weblog and certainly enjoyed this blog. More than likely I’m going to bookmark your blog . You absolutely come with impressive articles. Regards for sharing with us your website.


Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *