Can We Measure Racial Resentment?

Can We Measure Racial Resentment?

1491 views

Barack Obama’s presidency and Donald Trump’s success have reignited an interest among political scientists in quantifying racism.  However, racism has proven difficult to measure in surveys, as most participants will not voluntarily describe themselves as prejudiced.  Many political scientists and pundits will nevertheless use the limited available methods to study racism, but some of these methods are flawed and lead to dubious conclusions.  Specifically, the use of the Racial Resentment Scale inadvertently identifies facets of conservatism as bigotry.  This mischaracterization skews perceptions about American conservatism, and, more importantly, it inaccurately depicts the extent and nature of racism in America.

The Racial Resentment Scale seeks to measure animosity towards African Americans by asking respondents if they agree or disagree with certain statements.  Examples of such statements include- “It’s really a matter of some people not trying hard enough; if blacks would only try harder they could be just as well off as whites” and “Generations of slavery and discrimination have created conditions that make it difficult for blacks to work their way out of the lower class.”  The responses are then used to evaluate a person’s level of racial resentment.

Surveys have found that, in aggregate, Republicans score higher on the Racial Resentment Scale than Democrats.  Furthermore, in the 2016 Republican Primary, Trump supporters were more highly rated on racial resentment than both those who supported a different candidate in 2016 and those who supported previous Republican presidential nominees.  From these results, political scientists and pundits have often concluded that Republicans, particularly Trump supporters, are politically motivated by racial resentment.

However, other political scientists have questioned the validity of the Racial Resentment Scale.  They argue that answers interpreted as “racially resentful” could just as easily indicate an aversion to government assistance to the poor, an ignorance of societal barriers that African Americans face, or a belief in the “just world phenomenon”—the idea that people tend to get what they deserve because the world is just, so individuals are responsible for their own circumstances.  Given that the Republican Party believes in less government involvement and is more optimistic of upward mobility, it stands to reason that those within the party would score higher on the Racial Resentment Scale irrespective of actual prejudice.  One would expect them to reject government aid to African Americans due to an aversion to government action than racial animosity.

Riley K. Carney and Ryan D. Enos’ 2017 paper, “Conservatism, Just World Belief, and Racism: An Experimental Investigation of the Attitudes Measured by Modern Racism Scales” has generated findings that corroborate this expectation.  When administering the Racial Resentment Scale survey but substituting various ethnicities such as “Albanian” or even “Some Whites,” Carney and Enos saw no aggregate difference in response.  This indicates that the seemingly racially resentful answers to the Racial Resentment Scale may not be motivated by hostility towards African Americans.  Thus, such opinions may be motivated by reasons independent of race.

Other revealing results stem from a 2005 paper by Stanley Feldman and Leonie Huddy: “Racial Resentment and White Opposition to Race‐Conscious Programs: Principles or Prejudice?”  In this piece, Feldman and Huddy applied the Racial Resentment Scale to both conservatives and liberals.  Furthermore, they supplemented this scale by gauging their level of support for both college scholarship programs targeting whites and programs targeting blacks.  They found that, for conservatives, support for proposed aid to both black and white constituencies decreased as racial resentment increased.  Thus, “racial resentment” in conservatives at least partially correlates with decreased support for increased assistance to anyone, not just African Americans.  Once again, this indicates that the Racial Resentment Scale measures conservative fiscal sensibilities even as it also measures prejudice.

Make no mistake, the Racial Resentment Scale can certainly measure prejudice when the mitigating variables of conservatism are not present.  When applying the scale to liberals, Huddy and Feldman found a very clear correlation between racial resentment and declining support for blacks—and also no corresponding decline in support for assisting whites (in fact, support for whites slightly increased as racial resentment increased).  Thus, the decline in support for poor blacks (as the racial resentment score increased) can be attributed to an actual increase in racial resentment rather than the decline in support for government assistance.

Moreover, this study does not absolve conservatism of charges of racism.  Conservatives’ support for African American assistance did indeed decline at a faster rate than their support for white assistance (as racial resentment increased).  Thus, this study shows that racism, in some form, is still pervasive and in need of measurement.  But it also demonstrates that the Racial Resentment Scale is incapable of providing conclusive results.  The scale’s tendency to confuse racism with competing variables, such as fiscal conservatism or skepticism towards claims of oppression, obfuscates any findings it may produce.

Defenders of the Racial Resentment Scale will sometimes point out that the scale does not claim to measure racism (at least, not in the traditional sense), but rather racial resentment (hence the name).  This defense is nominally accurate; in political science, there is in fact a difference between “racism” and “racial resentment.”  In their 1996 book, Divided by Color (pg. 293), Donald Kinder and Lynn Sanders define racial resentment (which they also refer to as “new racism”) as “the conjunction of whites’ feelings towards blacks and their support for American values, especially secularized versions of the Protestant ethic.”  They assert that today’s racial politics are less defined by a belief in the innate inferiority of African Americans and more by a sense that they fail to live up to traditional conceptions of American values (such as hard work or adherence to Protestant morality).

However, this clarification fails as a defense, because it does not recognize that the Racial Resentment Scale faces criticism for measuring sensibilities (such as a belief in individuality) that are, at least in theory, independent of any form of racial bias.  The term “Racial Resentment Scale” therefore remains a misnomer, as the scale fails to gauge what it purports to measure.  Perhaps, as Cindy D. Kam and Camille D. Burge have suggested, the Racial Resentment Scale ought to be recast as the Structural versus Individual Attributions for Black Americans’ Economic and Social Status (SIA) scale.  Because, ultimately, the scale does a far better job at gauging people’s interpretations of racial politics than it does at explaining the factors that drive these beliefs.

The Racial Resentment Scale is not the only way political scientists can measure the effect of racial attitudes on politics.  For example, a 2016 study conducted by Gregory Major Blascovich, Alison Blodorn, and Brenda Major found that white people with a strong racial identity became more likely to support Trump if they were told that members of nonwhite groups will outnumber white people in the United States by 2042.  And another recent study by Christopher Federico, Howard Lavine, and Matthew Luttig found that Trump supporters were more likely to oppose a housing-assistance policy if shown an image of a black person beforehand.  These are substantive findings, and this is because the studies succeed in isolating race as the influential variable.

Unfortunately, methods like these are too limited to replace the Racial Resentment Scale because they can only test for differences between groups instead of determining the racial attitudes of individuals.  Indeed, despite its flaws, the Racial Resentment Scale has been widely used for a reason:  it ascertains a level of racial resentment for every single survey respondent.  Each participant’s racial resentment score is therefore connected to all of their other answers.  This allows political scientists to treat racial resentment as a variable and explore its relationship with other variables (it helps that this is done with only four questions that can easily be attached to any survey).  While useful in certain respects, the aforementioned experiments cannot do this; they can only compare direct results pertaining to subgroups (i.e. liberals vs. conservatives, Trump voters vs. non-Trump voters).  Thus, political scientists are still in search of a suitable alternative to the Racial Resentment Scale.

In conclusion, I must note that I am in no way arguing that racial attitudes have no (or even just a negligible) effect on politics.  Nor do I wish to sweep the Republican Party’s relationship with identity politics under the rug.  On the contrary—as a libertarian, I have great interest in understanding the degree to which the party of limited government relies on racial attitudes instead of principle (to say nothing of racism’s inherent ugliness).  It is this interest – an interest in understanding the nature and prevalence of contemporary bigotry as opposed to merely confirming that it exists– that leads me to conclude that we must find a better measuring stick than the Racial Resentment Scale.

Image Source

About author

John Konicki

John is a sophomore from Oakland County, Michigan. He is majoring in Political Science and Russian Studies. He is interested in political culture and history, and hopes to become either a political science professor or a pundit. In addition to writing for Vanderbilt Political Review, he is also the chair of Vanderbilt’s AEI Executive Council, is a site leader for Alternative Spring Break, and participates in Model UN.

Comments
  • fitflops sale clearance#1

    March 17, 2019

    I would like to express appreciation to the writer just for rescuing me from this particular situation. Just after checking throughout the the web and obtaining basics that were not pleasant, I assumed my entire life was over. Existing without the presence of approaches to the issues you’ve solved through your guide is a critical case, and ones that could have in a negative way affected my entire career if I hadn’t come across your site. Your own training and kindness in controlling the whole lot was invaluable. I’m not sure what I would’ve done if I had not discovered such a point like this. I can also at this time relish my future. Thank you so much for your expert and sensible guide. I will not hesitate to endorse your blog to anybody who desires guidance about this issue.

    Reply
  • off-white#2

    March 16, 2019

    My spouse and i ended up being quite cheerful that Louis could conclude his survey because of the precious recommendations he obtained in your site. It’s not at all simplistic just to choose to be giving out tricks people today may have been trying to sell. And now we understand we’ve got you to be grateful to for this. The most important illustrations you’ve made, the easy site menu, the friendships your site make it easier to foster – it’s everything spectacular, and it’s making our son and our family feel that that topic is exciting, which is certainly extraordinarily important. Thank you for all!

    Reply
  • moncler jackets#3

    January 11, 2019

    I must voice my appreciation for your kindness in support of people that require help with this particular concern. Your very own dedication to passing the solution all over has been amazingly productive and have continually empowered most people like me to achieve their desired goals. Your entire important guide denotes much a person like me and even more to my office colleagues. Thank you; from everyone of us.

    Reply
  • nike huarache#4

    January 10, 2019

    Thank you so much for providing individuals with remarkably terrific chance to read articles and blog posts from this web site. It’s always very pleasurable plus stuffed with a great time for me and my office mates to visit your blog at the very least thrice every week to find out the new stuff you will have. And definitely, I am just usually fulfilled with your striking tips you serve. Certain 2 tips on this page are completely the simplest we’ve ever had.

    Reply
  • kate spade handbags#5

    January 10, 2019

    I and also my friends appeared to be digesting the excellent things from your web page then then developed a horrible feeling I had not expressed respect to the web blog owner for them. My ladies were glad to learn them and have in effect in reality been enjoying them. Thanks for actually being well thoughtful as well as for deciding upon some wonderful useful guides millions of individuals are really desperate to learn about. Our sincere apologies for not expressing appreciation to earlier.

    Reply
  • kobe shoes#6

    January 9, 2019

    I wanted to create you one little word so as to thank you yet again just for the beautiful ideas you have shown on this page. It was quite wonderfully generous of people like you giving freely exactly what a few people would’ve supplied as an ebook to earn some profit on their own, particularly now that you might well have tried it if you ever decided. These strategies likewise served to become great way to be aware that other people have similar desire really like mine to figure out a great deal more on the topic of this matter. I believe there are millions of more pleasant sessions ahead for individuals who read through your blog.

    Reply
  • adidas yeezy#7

    January 8, 2019

    My husband and i felt very joyful when Emmanuel managed to carry out his analysis through the precious recommendations he gained through your site. It’s not at all simplistic just to happen to be freely giving key points that people may have been trying to sell. And we realize we need you to be grateful to for this. The main explanations you made, the straightforward website navigation, the relationships you will give support to engender – it’s everything astonishing, and it’s making our son in addition to our family feel that that topic is cool, which is certainly very important. Thanks for the whole lot!

    Reply
  • yeezy boost#8

    January 8, 2019

    Thank you for your own work on this website. My aunt take interest in carrying out research and it’s really easy to see why. My partner and i hear all of the powerful form you provide priceless tactics through the web blog and in addition welcome contribution from people on the content then my simple princess is now understanding so much. Enjoy the rest of the new year. You have been conducting a brilliant job.

    Reply
  • nba jerseys#9

    January 6, 2019

    I simply wanted to thank you very much once more. I’m not certain the things I would have done in the absence of the entire strategies discussed by you regarding my problem. It actually was the challenging setting in my opinion, however , discovering a new specialised tactic you managed that forced me to cry for gladness. I’m happy for your service and expect you comprehend what a powerful job that you’re getting into educating many others with the aid of your web page. I am certain you’ve never met any of us.

    Reply
  • nike air force#10

    January 4, 2019

    I together with my guys were studying the great information and facts from your website and all of a sudden I had a horrible suspicion I had not thanked the web site owner for those tips. All of the women happened to be for that reason thrilled to study them and already have quite simply been enjoying these things. Thanks for genuinely so kind and then for deciding upon such exceptional tips most people are really desperate to be informed on. My personal honest apologies for not expressing appreciation to earlier.

    Reply
  • nike air max#11

    January 4, 2019

    Thanks so much for providing individuals with a very wonderful chance to read critical reviews from this website. It is often so good and jam-packed with a great time for me and my office co-workers to search your web site no less than thrice weekly to study the fresh guidance you will have. And definitely, I’m certainly fulfilled concerning the very good tricks served by you. Selected two tips in this post are unquestionably the simplest I have ever had.

    Reply
  • moncler jackets#12

    January 3, 2019

    I really wanted to write a small note so as to express gratitude to you for all of the fantastic tricks you are sharing on this site. My time consuming internet search has now been compensated with brilliant know-how to exchange with my family members. I would admit that most of us readers actually are unquestionably fortunate to dwell in a notable community with many awesome people with very beneficial tactics. I feel really grateful to have used the webpage and look forward to tons of more brilliant times reading here. Thank you once again for all the details.

    Reply
  • russell westbrook shoes#13

    January 2, 2019

    I truly wanted to write down a brief remark in order to say thanks to you for all of the great recommendations you are giving out at this website. My considerable internet look up has at the end of the day been compensated with really good concept to share with my partners. I ‘d admit that many of us site visitors actually are really fortunate to dwell in a wonderful site with many awesome people with great tactics. I feel extremely lucky to have encountered your entire website and look forward to tons of more amazing moments reading here. Thank you once more for a lot of things.

    Reply
  • yeezy boost 350 v2#14

    January 2, 2019

    I just wanted to write down a simple note in order to appreciate you for some of the amazing tactics you are sharing here. My considerable internet research has finally been rewarded with useful knowledge to write about with my company. I ‘d express that most of us visitors are definitely blessed to be in a wonderful community with so many awesome professionals with valuable plans. I feel really fortunate to have discovered your entire web site and look forward to so many more thrilling minutes reading here. Thanks a lot once again for all the details.

    Reply
  • balenciaga#15

    January 1, 2019

    I in addition to my pals were found to be analyzing the excellent tactics found on the website and so suddenly I got a terrible feeling I never expressed respect to the website owner for those techniques. All of the boys are actually very interested to read them and have now unquestionably been taking advantage of these things. I appreciate you for actually being very kind as well as for figuring out some terrific subject areas most people are really desirous to learn about. My honest regret for not expressing gratitude to you sooner.

    Reply
  • michael kors outlet#16

    January 1, 2019

    Thanks a lot for providing individuals with an extraordinarily splendid opportunity to read articles and blog posts from here. It is often very excellent and as well , stuffed with amusement for me personally and my office fellow workers to visit your blog more than three times weekly to find out the newest stuff you have got. And lastly, I am just at all times motivated for the awesome strategies served by you. Selected two points in this article are essentially the most effective we’ve had.

    Reply
  • Chris Orlet#17

    December 26, 2018

    more important. no ly

    Reply
  • SoineedidaTot#18

    December 22, 2018

    “At first锛?they did not have much idea what they should do锛?and were reluctant to attend meetings锛?said Liu Huili锛?head of the government office in the community. At the end of August锛?she heard that Chen’s husband Fu was seriously ill.The Nomura economists said they expected one more interest rate cut in the second quarter of 2015, with RRR reductions in each quarter of next year. It is important now more than ever that parents teach their children how to cope with negative life experiences in the absence of misbehavior or else their children will feel compelled to misbehave after each negative life experience. Drivers under 25 are actually asked to pay higher insurance charges, but are otherwise capable of rent a car with no hassles. Most residents are seniors who were resettled here when the buildings were new and their original residences were demolished. [url=http://www.cheapncaacollegeshop.com/]Cheap College Jerseys From China[/url].[url=http://www.cheapncaacollegeshop.com/]Cheap NFL Jerseys China Wholesale[/url].[url=http://www.cheapncaacollegeshop.com/]Cheap Jerseys[/url].Even if your current residence needs a lot of work, you can still rely on these buyers. In order to eliminate the fat from the well, you need to combine exercise with a very healthy diet, this is the regular pattern. With proper opportunities锛?an aging population can bring its own demographic dividend.Choose the Very bestThe Search engine optimization Group is a entire-services lookup engine optimization corporation with the knowledge to optimize your site and meet all of your world wide web structure and world-wide-web promoting requires. In order to eliminate the fat from the well, you need to combine exercise with a very healthy diet, this is the regular pattern. It was not probable in past as no one could acquire stuff on the internet.”Visit my site锛歨ttp://www.cheapncaacollegeshop.com/

    Reply
  • SoineedidaTot#19

    December 22, 2018

    “HK – news) on November 21 shocked markets by cutting interest rates for the first time in more than two years to kickstart the slowing economy and analysts said they expect further easing measures in the new year.5) Payday loans need to by no means be taken out in purchase to pay off yet another payday mortgage. Fashion sports is a term appointed to identify a class that’s more or less does the same job as a professional instrument in terms of looks and accurate functioning, but doesn’t put to use the protective parameters fully. Marketing professionals do the work with expertise and ensures that the objective is served i. In this kind of cases Business course of action mapping exhibits the missing hyperlinks that may possibly have resulted in slag, misplaced possibilities and missed credits or invoices. For every brand there must be a set core pattern around which the variations must weave out further. [url=http://www.wholesalenfljerseys-cheap.com/]Wholesale Jerseys Cheap[/url]. But it is not going to impress someone with deliberate snobbery.What Is The Variance In between Dollars Advance And Payday Loans? Money advance is also acknowledged as a payday loan.[url=http://www.wholesalenfljerseys-cheap.com/]Wholesale NFL Jerseys China Outlet[/url]. Most residents are seniors who were resettled here when the buildings were new and their original residences were demolished.Well, if you opt for the Sell My House Fast option, you don’t have to do anything other than leave your contact details in the right place and offer more information regarding the condition of your property.[url=http://www.wholesalenfljerseys-cheap.com/]Cheap NFL Jerseys[/url]. With proper opportunities??? an aging population can bring its own demographic dividend. From time to time bad credit ratings might result in approval troubles with unsecured personal loans and for that same cause you’d want to take into account payday loans as they are generally accredited inside the exact same say or 24 several hours.”Visit my site???http://www.wholesalenfljerseys-cheap.com/

    Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *